patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Woodbury ‘Rooster’ Mom Weighs In On ‘Tiger’ Mothering

Delving into the parenting messages in the recent bestseller, "Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother."

 

“Tiger Mother” Amy Chua will be in Minneapolis on Friday to speak and promote her best-selling book, Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother.

It’s available at Barnes & Noble in the "parenting" section, which may cause some of you who’ve read it to choke on your morning coffee.

I’m heading over with some Woodbury women to see Chua. But first, this “rooster” mother weighs in on “tiger mothering.”

If you’re just hearing of Chua, you might live under a rock. Basically, Chua’s been skewered in the press for the heavy-handed parenting style describes in her book. A style she calls Chinese parenting but later expands the definition as a cultural clash of immigrant deference versus western rebellion.

She comes off a bit extreme… if not completely nuts. Like when she describes spending tremendous energy locating a piano so her daughter can practice for a few hours per day while on vacation.

But my sense is that Chua misfired with an attempt at brutal honesty. She exposed the intense nature of her personality with a sense of ironic humor that falls flat.

That’s unfortunate, because she got some things right. Like American parents slathering praise on their kids for the lowest of tasks.

I recall my own child crying once when his pinewood derby car didn’t win. We tried to mollify him with a trophy. He rejected it, saying: “That’s just for participation.”

Kids get it. And thankfully budget constraints seem to have eliminated ostentatious participation trophies. Expecting to be rewarded for non-performance shouldn’t be the modern opiate of our whining masses.

Chua also recognizes that we live in a meritocracy where hard work leads to better opportunities for future success. We can debate a kinder, gentler way than Chua’s of setting expectations or defining success. But at least she sets some standards.

She’s involved. Successful kids rarely come from homes with disengaged parents. She doesn’t only demand excellence. She provides a framework to achieve it.

Some complain about helicopter parents overly involved in their children’s lives. I’d argue that in an increasingly competitive global society that structure, guidance and networking of involved parents are necessary for children’s achievement.

That’s very different from never letting kids learn by doing or by failing. There’s a balance. But I’d lean toward more involvement than less.

Chua’s right that it should be virtuous to raise children who are not vulgar, lazy or entitled. Allowing kids to “follow their hearts” can lead to finding those hearts on the couch striving to beat the next level of Mafia Mario Madness or worse.

Kids need direction and often need to be nudged (pushed) to achieve worthwhile things that they’re capable of achieving.

Granted, each person has a different aptitude. Chua got that part wrong (plus the name-calling bit). She knows it and attempts to describe her transformation from hard-line, one-size-fits-all, control-freak parent to moderated cheerleader supporting her second child’s pursuits. Sadly, she comes off as hypocritical rather than enlightened.

Overall, I think Chua ponders what many parents do. How much choice should we allow our children?

Related Topics: Amy Chua, Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother, Parenting, Tiger Mother, and Woodbury
What do you think of Chua's parenting style? Tell us in the comments.

Kathryn Z Berg, MA, CCH

12:28 pm on Tuesday, February 7, 2012

I have not read The Battle Hymn of the TIger Mother. I don't plan to either. I feel like it is so easy to parent other people's children. Chua is an ambitious parent. Others are not so, and feel that their kids need to have time to be kids once in awhile.

As a classical homeopath, I hear all kinds of stories about kids who had tiger mothers and fathers and they have a high level of anxiety as adults. But Mom or Dad were probably pushed the same way and cannot break out of this need to have children who are high achievers and doesn't know any other way to do it. I feel sorry for the children.

Reply

Qin Tang

6:20 am on Wednesday, February 8, 2012

I have mixed feelings about the Tiger Mother book, as I wrote about in my post http://onmymind.areavoices.com/2011/03/14/mixed-feelings-about-the-tiger-mother-book/
The book is an easy and interesting read, challenges the western parenting style, gives parents something to think about, but Chua is too harsh and extreme, somewhat showy and sensetional.
Most Chinese parents don't consider Chua's parenting style as Chinese and distant themselves from it.
I am interested in her Friday talk at UofM, but I am not going. Please write a follow-up and share your thoughts and findings after the meeting.
Thanks.

Reply

Leave a comment